without a key (4/5)Nate, Dan, Blair, Serena, Jenny. Also Chuck.
s1 AU; Nate left town instead of Serena.
PG13. 6228 words.
Summary: Dan is calling again, and again Nate hits
ignore, turning up his music as though doing so will tune out his brain.
Dan is calling again, and again Nate hits
ignore, turning up his music as though doing so will tune out his brain.
They haven't spoken since –
Nate turns the music up and up as he runs, even though the whole thing is an exercise in stupidity. Half the music on his iPod is Dan's, anyway.
Nate goes to visit his dad but he's fidgety and uncomfortable the whole time, unable to follow the thread of conversation because he's thinking about the last time he was here, how Dan brought him and then waited around until he was done.
"Hey, Dad," he interrupts. His dad is surprised enough to actually stop and look at him. "I don't know how much you know, but I, uh… I really messed up with Blair. Badly."
"Get her some flowers," the Captain says. "Candy. Hell, give her one of those family heirlooms your mother's always on about. She'll forgive you."
"No, that's not what I mean." Nate suppresses a little huff of impatience. "I think it was for the best, not – not that I went about it right, but in the end… In the end it had to happen. The thing is –"
"Blair is a good girl," his dad says firmly. "She's been there for you since nursery school. Do what you have to do to make up with her. You won't regret it."
That sigh had still been rumbling somewhere in Nate's chest, and he releases it now, slowly. "Okay, Dad. Thanks."
Once out on the street, Nate hesitates. He could just get on the train home. He could go home and sit in his room not doing his homework, ignoring everything and everyone. He could very easily do that, but instead he starts walking until he's in front of Dan's building. And then he goes up.
His biggest fear is honestly what to expect from the Humphreys as a whole, but they seem unaware that anything out of the ordinary is going on with Nate and Dan. They even look pleased to see Nate.
"We're so glad you boys aren't fighting anymore," Mrs. Humphrey (
Allison, Nate corrects mentally) says warmly. And for whatever reason, Nate's ears go pink.
He knocks on Dan's door and takes a deep breath when Dan answers, steeling himself before going inside.
Dan hadn't been expecting him, of course, and he does a little bit of a double take, going from relaxed to tense so fast he might've hurt himself. "Nate," he breathes, just like that – just like he had at cotillion, when they were alone.
"Hey." Nate leans back against the closed door, feeling every inch of the distance between them.
There's an awkward beat before Dan launches into what eventually reveals itself to be a lengthy apology. "I crossed a line and took advantage and it – I should
not have done that, I'm really sorry –"
"How long did you –" Nate falters. "Have you…felt like that…for long?"
Dan goes slightly red. "Does that matter?"
Nate bites his lip, toys with it between his teeth until he notices Dan noticing. "Why?"
"Why what?"
Why me? Nate thinks, but doesn't say. He clears his throat. "You don't have to be sorry."
Dan straightens up but doesn't stand, doesn't bridge the gap. He wets his lips. "I don’t?"
Nate starts to move forward, which seems to jolt Dan so that he's getting to his feet, moving too – and then there's Rufus' voice from the other room loudly declaring dinner is ready. Both of them flinch, twin looks of annoyance on their faces, but Dan laughs and, relieved, Nate echoes it.
As they turn to leave the room, Dan puts his hand on Nate's back, right between his shoulder blades – half directing, half friendly. Nate feels it all through the meal like a brand. He hadn't expected Dan touching him to feel different – he hadn't really expected Dan touching him at all.
Dan walks him out after, not an altogether unusual thing but just odd enough that the rest of the family seems aware of it. Nate's heart beats hard in his chest, knowing that even though they know about Dan now, they don't – they wouldn't assume he and Nate were –
In the vestibule Nate turns to say goodbye and he's suddenly shoved up against the wall, Dan's mouth hot on his. Nate doesn't mean to but he groans and he grips Dan's shirt, digs his fingers into Dan's arms. It's like the last time they kissed, and not like that at all.
"See you tomorrow," Dan murmurs, and then nearly smirks, looking so proud of himself that Nate cups his cheeks and kisses him again.
"Tomorrow," Nate repeats. He leaves Dan looking happily dazed. The feeling in his own chest is lighter than it's been all day.
Now there's only school to worry about.
School is…not what Nate expected.
In some ways, it is: Blair is definitely furious, stalking the halls with her entourage like personified thunderclouds. Nate is tripped at least a dozen times by five different girls. Chuck is so smugly triumphant that if Nate hadn't already known the blast was his doing, he'd figure it out real quick. But otherwise, with everyone else at school, it's like Nate is the golden boy again, getting handshakes and high-fives.
"Scoring with
Serena," the boys say, all variations on the same theme, "Congratu-fucking-lations, man."
"That's not how it is," Nate tries, to no avail. "She's my
friend," but no one wants to hear it.
He doesn't know if Blair and Serena are even speaking, because Serena isn't there on Monday – or on Tuesday. There are plenty of pictures on Gossip Girl of her throwing back shots, puking in club bathrooms, dancing on tables. Nate knows what people are calling her; he hears it everywhere he goes. They treat him like a hero, Serena like anything but.
It's his fault. He knows that – only it seems like no one else does.
On Wednesday he sees Serena being taken to the headmistress' office, unsteady and giggling with her arm in her English teacher's. He wants to say something but doesn't know what to say or how to say it, and he knows everyone would get the wrong idea if they saw.
"God, can you believe her," he hears one sophomore girl say to another. "She doesn't even
care."
"And you know Nate and Blair were just getting back together, too," her friend adds disapprovingly.
Nate is fed up enough that he's tempted to interrupt, but really, what could he say?
He tries to talk to Blair even though he knows it's dangerous and stupid. She's never alone at school so it must be done in front of the squadron of girls, but Nate nevertheless screws up his courage and goes to apologize.
"Blair?"
He knows with one look that it's a mistake. Blair looks at him not so much with the coldness she'd had upon his return but a soul-deep
anger. Her eyes flash but she doesn't speak, instead pointedly turning away from him. Almost as one, all of the girls narrow their eyes at him and turn away too.
"Okay, I deserve that," Nate sighs, but it's no use – she's not going to speak to him.
As Nate leaves, he sees Dan across the courtyard, perched on a table with the lip of a paper coffee cup caught between his teeth as he rearranges papers and books in his bag. He's alone. He's a mess, half his belongings spread out all around him. He glances up like maybe he'd been watching, checking on Nate even as he went about his business, and the sheepish wave he gives seems confirmation enough of that.
Nate tries not to smile, feeling an odd twinge in his chest, possibly a flutter.
The one place Nate remains distinctly
un-heroic is at home. Halfway through dinner he's already plotting his escape from his mother's exasperated prying, that way she has of making him feel both impossibly stupid and utterly insignificant.
Anne never asks where he's going but sometimes he wishes she would. Right now he imagines telling her the truth:
I'm going to Brooklyn to kiss a boy, because apparently I do that now. The thought fills him with equal parts terror and exhilaration.
That's what he's going to do. He's going to Brooklyn not just as an escape from home, not just to hang out, but with a specific goal in mind. He's spent the entire week making conversation before class and copying Dan's homework, wondering if Dan is ever going to touch him again and waiting for Dan to do so. Nate has spent a week teetering on the edge of desire and discomfort, because he might die if anyone knew about this but that doesn't stop him wanting it.
The thing that's been confusing him since cotillion is how natural it feels. Kissing Dan had been a relief, a calm spot in a storm. If his parents knew they'd probably lose it; Nate knows how it goes in his family with things like this. It's be all about burying it and moving on, pushing him on Blair or someone similar. He could never tell them about this.
But right now he can't even think that far ahead, because he doesn't even know what
this is.
Nate had anticipated disappearing into Dan's room like they usually did, but apparently the entire Humphrey clan is spending Friday night watching black and white movies. Dan's dad has his arm around Dan's mom at one end of the couch, looking cozier than any parents Nate's ever known; Jenny is sort of sprawled in the middle taking up the most space, her head on Dan's shoulder. Nate is stuffed between the arm of the couch and Dan, who is doing a very good job of being completely as ease, as though they aren't pressed together shoulder to knee.
Nate sits through two movies (two movies he's
already seen, thanks to Blair) and tries not to be obviously restless, but it's a lot harder than it should be. He feels like he can't move at all because jostling Dan would in turn jostle Jenny, and then Dan's parents, all down the line. It's annoying and the movies are kind of boring and Dan keeps brushing against him in little ways – the back of his wrist against Nate's fingers, his knuckles against Nate's arm.
It takes Nate an embarrassingly long time to realize Dan is doing it on purpose.
Eventually, after what feels like an eternity of impatience, everyone begins to dissipate. Dan's parents have some last-minute things at the gallery to take care of before some big show; Jenny has a party at Hazel's to go to. She shoots Nate a slightly apologetic look, as though he has anything to do with her personal life, but she seems pretty pleased about it altogether.
And then it's just Nate and Dan.
Dan shifts over on the couch a little so they're no longer touching and grabs the remote. "Hungry?" he asks. "My dad made chili."
Nate doesn't have the ability to articulate his anxious over-eagerness, and he's slightly cross that Dan doesn't just take the reins immediately like he had last time. "No, I'm okay."
Dan slides a glance Nate's way. "Thirsty?" he asks, and Nate finally catches onto the teasing in his voice, the smile on his face.
"Dude, not cool," Nate huffs, unable to keep from smiling himself. He reaches over to grip a handful of Dan's shirt but then falters awkwardly. Deciding to bulldoze through it, he takes a breath and leans in, watches Dan's lips part and then –
"Wait," Dan says. "Should we – should we talk about what's going on here?"
The answer to that is probably yes.
Nate nods a little as he leans closer again, satisfied when Dan's eyes begin to fall closed. "Sure. Let me just do this first –"
Fifteen minutes later finds them stretched out together on the couch, legs tangled and clothes all twisted around. Nate had started out on top but then they'd shifted, kept shifting around each other, trying to find a way to walk the line of too much and not enough – a line Nate knew very well thanks to Blair but had never been nervous about crossing before now.
He hasn't kissed anyone like this since Blair. Meaning: clothes too hot on hotter skin, hands skimming bodies with something akin to frustration, feeling bound by both expectation and apprehension. Every boundary seeming impossible to cross until you've crossed it.
Nate is trying to be a gentleman, touching only the safe parts of Dan – his neck, his face, his arms; or no-man's-lands like the length of his side, a covered shoulder. It only makes him more conscious of the parts of Dan he hadn't known he wanted to touch. Dan, for his part, is a lot less controlled; his hands keep pressing up against Nate's chest or digging hard into his thigh. He has less experience with this, Nate thinks.
Finally Nate has to pull back, though it takes several attempts, neither of them quite willing to stop. "Shit."
Dan laughs a little but Nate means it: shit. One kiss, even two – whatever, stuff happens. But the blood rushing around his veins, his heart thumping hard in his chest, the hips he is keeping
very much away from Dan's – that means something. A something Nate is not altogether prepared to address.
"Somehow I don't see a conversation happening now," Dan says dryly. He tugs at his collar like he needs a breather. His shirt is rucked up just the tiniest bit from the switching of position. Nate really wants to – "Eyes up here, buddy."
Abashed, Nate meets his eyes. There are a million questions waiting there: what is this, what does it mean, where will it go? Nate knows things like that always get answered eventually, one way or another, and it's not entirely a stalling tactic when he says, "You're the first boy I ever kissed."
How could he not have noticed, until now?
"Back at you." Dan is rubbing soft circles at the edge of Nate's jaw. "I really –" But he laughs again without finishing, shaking his head.
Nate likes that laugh. "What?"
"Not in a million years did I think
this would ever – that's you'd ever
want to do this. At all, but especially with
me."
"You're the one who kissed me," Nate points out.
"Yeah, but I wasn't thinking about…well, anything," Dan says. "I wasn't thinking about what would happen."
"So why did you do it?"
Dan half-shrugs. "I just wanted to. You were so… " His hand falls away and so does his gaze, something embarrassed in the motion. "I had a crush on you for a while."
The last few months hardly constitute a while, but it's still longer than Nate was aware of. "Yeah?"
Dan wets his lips, a nervous, almost furtive gesture. "Well. Do you remember the first time we met?"
"Yeah, right after I came back," Nate says, a little surprised. That immediately? "At that café."
"No…" Dan is definitely embarrassed. "Uh, it was at this party. Like two years ago."
After some halting explanations, Nate remembers the party – Britt Martin's Halloween party freshman year of high school, before Blair had been settled enough at Constance to take over all celebratory duties.
And then vaguely, vaguely, Nate remembers Dan.
That dumb party, Blair telling him to
mingle and
stop moping. She'd tiptoed up to whisper some naughty promise in his ear that he remembers being too drunk to take advantage of later. Serena brought Carter Baizen and got high as fuck, made out with him on the couch in the living room and then left for somewhere more exciting.
Nate had gone into the crowd with a drink in his hand and seen a boy leaning awkwardly against the wall, watching the party with alert eyes, wild curly hair hanging into his face. Nate had held out a hand and said, "I'm Nate Archibald."
"I know," the boy said, then looked ready to chastise himself. "Uh, I'm Dan."
"Dan," he repeated, tried a smile and failed. "Want a drink?"
A hopeful gleam in those dark eyes. "Uh, sure."
Nate wandered off and never did wander back. Chuck fed him shots and he passed out in the empty porcelain tub.
"Your hair was different," Nate offers. "Longer."
Dan nods, self-deprecating smile on his face. "If a fourteen year old girl ever offers to give you a haircut," he says. "Say no."
Nate feels suddenly very strange. It's worse than realizing he'd probably sat next to Dan in classes without realizing. It's worse to know that they'd actually spoken, that Dan was just…
there, out there wanting something that Nate had no conception of. And now they're here. Making out in Dan's living room.
"This whole time?" Nate says.
"You're freaked out." It's not really an answer, but it also might as well be yes.
"No, not…" Not freaked out. A little unsettled, maybe. Dan has had a crush on him for years, had a crush on him the whole time they were getting to know each other, was his friend but really – "I should get going. I mean, even my mom will notice if I'm gone half the night."
She wouldn't, though. Once the sleeping pill kicks in, she doesn't notice a thing until her alarm goes off in the morning.
Dan is upset. "I shouldn't have said anything. I just thought it would be weirder if I didn't… I… It's not like I was laying in wait or something, I just thought you were cute –"
"No, it's cool," Nate says, and presses a quick kiss to Dan's mouth like that will, indeed, make it cool. "I really just gotta go."
And he does, carried out of the loft by the same pressing eagerness that had brought him there in the first place.
Nate gets a text from Dan as soon as he's emerged from the subway.
I didn't mean to freak you out.
Nate sighs and puts his phone away, putting off responding for now. He doesn't really want to go home yet but he doesn't know what else to do. So he does what he does: jogs around the park until his brain goes quiet. But it doesn't satisfy him for whatever reason; it doesn't settle him. He hasn't smoked in weeks, doesn't even have any weed left. He doesn't know what else to do with himself. He never had other hobbies.
Dan would read, probably.
Nate is not a reader.
He takes out his phone to finally text Dan back, since he's trying to be one of those people who faces things, but learning new tricks is a slow process so instead he finds himself calling Serena. He doesn't know why.
(He sort of knows why.)
Serena is drunk when she answers, and he knows this because instead of
hello, she says, "Woooooo!"
"Serena?" he tries, a little too loudly. He can't hear thumping music so she must not be at a club.
"Nate!" She sounds playfully admonishing. "You're not supposed to talk to me!"
"I know, but –" They haven't talked,
really talked, in so long. "Are you okay?"
"Yeah,
Dad," Serena laughs. She used to do that when she was really far gone – call him dad and Blair mom, mocking and sweet at once. It always bothered Nate, just a little.
"I want to –" He doesn't actually have any idea what he wants to say to Serena, only aware that
something must be said. "I'm sorry. I didn't – I didn't tell anyone. It was Chuck, you know – he saw us."
But Serena isn't listening, or at least is pretending not to listen. "Natie, we just got here, I gotta – Poppy, hold on –" There's the muffled sounds of movement, potentially getting out of a car if the sudden street noise is indicative of anything. "Nate, don't be sad, okay? Go do something fun."
"Like you are, right?" he sighs.
"Yup. Just like me," Serena says. "I always have the most fun, don't I?"
Nate ends up just going to Dan's the next afternoon unannounced. He seems to be getting good at the whole impolite dropping-in thing, and Dan has never seemed to mind before.
He isn't sure he's over it yet, his unspecified feelings of weirdness. But he knows that he wants to see Dan more than he doesn't. A lot more.
Mr. Humphrey waves Nate on to Dan's room without a thought. Dan's lying on his bed with one arm up behind his head and the other holding a paperback open. Sedaris. Dan likes him, Nate remembers. Dan doesn't start upon seeing him this time, but there is a clear wariness in the way he watches Nate.
Nate shuts the door casually and stands there a moment before asking, "Can I?" as he gestures to the bed. Dan nods, closing his book as he shoves over a few inches. Nate sits first and then lies beside Dan, letting his head lean into Dan's shoulder. He releases a long-held breath when Dan's fingers start to card through his hair.
"I really am sorry," Dan says. "I promise I wasn't writing Mrs. Dan Archibald in my notebooks or, like, calling your name out in my sleep or anything."
Nate almost smiles. "I know." He doesn't really feel like getting into it too much, but, "I don't want you to be…like, one of those people who has a crush on me. Not even me. That guy that's on Gossip Girl."
Expression thoughtful, Dan scrunches down a little so they're eye to eye. "I'm not," he says, amending, "I'm not
now. I like that guy who's trying really hard to make things right with his friends. Who cares about his family more than anything. Who has legitimately embarrassing taste in music, and, if we're being honest here, disgustingly nice arms."
"Ah, man, now you're making me blush." This time Nate does smile.
They do another thing Nate hasn't done for a very long while: press in close and cozy, not for any reason except proximity. The bed is comfortably warm and Dan gently strokes the back of Nate's neck, and soon enough they fall asleep together, just like that.
When they wake up, Nate is tucked into Dan's side, face smushed against his neck. "Your hand," he mumbles, "is on my ass."
He feels the slight, silent movement of Dan's laugh. "In my defense, it is a nice ass."
"Yeah?" Nate's lips trail inattentively over Dan's throat, still sleepy, trying to figure out just how to angle for a kiss.
"Really nice," Dan says, a little breathy as he tilts his head up.
"No, other way…" Nate feels Dan laugh again, but is rewarded by Dan tilting back down, right into the kiss.
For Christmas Dan gives Nate a copy of
The Lorax. "Dude," Nate says as he skims through the pages, "This is like the saddest book ever."
"I got it because of
The Petting Zoo," Dan says, a touch anxiously. "Remember?"
The book Nate hadn't been able to read without falling asleep – though he'd tried, very valiantly, and made it about fifty pages in before giving up entirely. "Are you sure this isn't a crack about my reading ability?"
"Nah," Dan says, leaning into him, "If I wanted to do that, I'd get you
Moby Dick and watch you squirm."
Nate hadn't known what to give Dan for Christmas. He doesn't actually have a wealth of experience buying gifts at all: Blair always put things on hold, and signed his name to gifts she got for other people. His parents did the same when it came to presents for each other. With the exception of Blair's birthday charm bracelet, Nate isn't sure he's ever gone out with the specific intention of giving someone something to make them happy.
He ends up giving Dan this soccer jersey he's had since forever, or so it feels. It's one of the first things he can remember genuinely wanting. He's not even sure why it meant so much to him, and it definitely no longer fits, but the idea of Dan having it is somehow comforting.
Dan looks like he gets it, at least. There's that soft look in his eyes that he has when they kiss. He puts it on his old Cabbage Patch doll, who swims in it, and they both get a laugh out of it that thankfully breaks up the sentimental moment.
Nate has been spending most of the days leading up to Christmas with the Humphreys. Unlike his own home, tastefully decorated by the same hired professional since Nate was three, the Humphrey loft is a mishmash of fairy lights and candy canes, tree hanging with hand-painted ornaments from when Dan and Jenny were toddlers. Allison always seems to be baking cookies. It's the kind of picturesque holiday that Nate's family tries to manufacture every year, though it always rings false.
"You know what, though?" Dan muses. "I wish it would snow. Christmas should be white and snowing. I'd even settle for Manhattan slush."
Nate nudges his nose against Dan's cheek. "I don't think that's a favor I can call in," he jokes.
"No?" Dan teases. "The Vanderbilts can't swing that one?"
"Mm, nope." Nate shakes his head with a slight wrinkle of his nose. "Political plotting, emotional detachment, really well-stocked bars – that they can do. Weather manipulation? Not so much."
They're ostensibly working on a history project, the last big thing they have to do before winter break kicks in, but so far all Nate has managed to do is give Dan a hickie just under his shirt collar. "I don't think this is very productive," Dan tried, at first, but he was easily swayed.
Eventually Nate just closes the textbooks and lets them drop heavily to the floor so he can kiss Dan until they fall back onto the bed. Dan always puts his hands on Nate's face when they kiss, and there is something so grounding about that, so soothing about the sweep of Dan's thumb over his cheek.
Almost immediately, Nate's sliding his leg between Dan's. That's a Blair habit too, though Nate knows he shouldn't be making comparisons; he just remembers how he felt like it was the only thing he
could do, because she'd turn down most anything else but she'd press down on his thigh while they kissed. The first time he'd done it with Dan, Dan bit Nate's lip so hard it was sore the rest of the night. So at least Nate knows it's a good move.
They still haven't really talked about this.
Nate kept waiting for it to turn awkward enough that they
had to, but it never really did. It's just like it was before, only better, more. That's how it had felt with Serena, too, in a way – continuing on a road they'd already started on, development of what was already there rather than something entirely new. Nate knows what people think of him, but he's not a total idiot: he realizes now that the reason he could never put words to how Dan made him feel was because Dan made him feel like
this and Nate was too scared to admit it.
Dan being a guy doesn't feel like the important distinction it should.
"Gotta ask you something," Nate murmurs.
"You know how to pick a moment," Dan tells him, hands slipping under Nate's shirt. "Whatever it is, yes."
Nate chuckles softly, and continues on anyway, "There's this thing coming up soon. It's dumb, you'd probably hate it, but I gotta go for my mom, it's like the only committee she's even still on –"
"Please don't bring up your mom while we're making out. That woman is terrifying."
Nate gives Dan a little chiding nip. "It's for charity, it's called the Snowflake Ball, and I know that's really lame –"
But now Dan pulls back, giving Nate a look both quizzical and disbelieving. "Are you asking me to be your date to something?"
"Sort of," Nate says, even though he knows he can't really offer that much. He touches Dan's mouth lightly. "It would be kind of…stealth, since I can't really…tell my mom. But I want you to come."
He waits nervously for Dan's response, because he knows this could be a lot to ask, and he wouldn't blame Dan for being uninterested or even offended. This is just Nate wanting too much as usual: to not totally disappoint his family for once, but still get something for himself.
"Yeah, I'll come." Dan dips down to kiss Nate briefly. "What, did you really think I'd say no?"
Relief floods Nate. "Just hoped you'd say yes. Wouldn't be any fun without you."
Dan smiles against his mouth. "You've already won, you don't have to keep making your case."
"Just being honest," Nate says. He says it teasingly but it's the truth, and not having to lie or hold back for once makes him sincerely happy.
After that it comes down to figuring out the details and making arrangements. Nate's mom won't let him off the hook without a(n official) date, and here Nate hits a brick wall: he doesn't want to lie to some random girl, but he also can't bring Serena as a friend without inciting a lot of drama. So he thinks the safest decision is to ask Jenny.
"Uh," Dan says. "You
do realize that to bring my little sister as your
date, you'll have to tell her you're my – uh, my friend but with kissing?"
Nate bites his lip. The thought had occurred to him. "Yeah." He hesitates, but, "I think that'll be okay. She won't tell anyone if we ask her not to, right?"
After a brief quiet moment, Dan's expression curious and thoughtful, he says, "If you're okay with that, then I'm okay with that."
Jenny's reaction is surprisingly understated, and she agrees to come along, mainly because, "Freshmen
never get to go to the Snowflake Ball." She pauses. "You know Blair's going to be furious no matter who you bring. And I'm probably not necessarily the least wrath-incurring choice."
Nate is a little surprised, if only because Jenny seems so sweet. He can't imagine her getting in trouble with anyone. "I think it'll be okay."
Jenny half-smiles. "Famous last words," she says. "Also, if you hurt my brother, I'll pretty much destroy you."
She says it with such simple straightforward seriousness that Nate revises his former opinion somewhat: sweet but with terrifying depths.
After that's settled, Nate takes a deep breath and calls Serena.
They haven't spoken since his last attempt at a phone call, when she was dizzy and drunk, unwilling to talk. She sounds different now – sober, or just sad. She sounds tired.
Nate starts with, "I have a favor to ask."
"Oh yeah?" Serena asks wryly. "What, go back in time and not fuck everything up like I always do?"
Nate swallows a little. "No, this wouldn't involve any time travel. Just putting on a dress and hanging out with Dan."
She listens while he outlines his pitch, asking her to be Dan's date one more time since they're friends now, though he gets it if she doesn't want to bother with functions populated by their classmates anymore. Serena doesn't say anything while she thinks about it, and he can just picture her sitting on her bed holding a pillow in her arms, maybe biting her lip.
"Why?" she asks plainly.
"Well, if you wanted to go, I figured it'd be good to know you had a friend," he says. "And, um… I don't want Dan to be too lonely."
"Uh-huh," she says.
Nate clears his throat. "He and I have gotten really close since I've been back, and I know you're good friends with him too, so…" He flounders.
Gently, Serena says, "It's okay, Nate."
He blinks. She couldn't possibly mean –
But then he thinks of how utterly unsurprised Jenny had been. Maybe he's a lot more obvious than he thinks. Maybe –
"I just think it would be nice if you came," he says. "I'm still sorry about…well, everything."
"Okay," Serena says, after another moment. "I'll come."
Anne is brittle and tense before the ball begins, but it seems to have gone off without a hitch.
The large ballroom is decorated to the last inch, cool and blue-lit and shadowy, with big screens scattered around the room showing wintery scenes. There are trees in every corner strung up with glittering white lights and fake snow falls softly and sparingly over the center of the dance floor. There's faux frost everywhere. Jenny makes a delighted little sound when they enter, clutching his arm tightly.
Serena drags Dan off to dance immediately. Nate is obscurely proud of her, the way she twirls right in the middle of the room like she doesn't care at all if anyone is talking about her. The way she can still have fun even though everyone
is talking about her.
Nate leaves Jenny to compare dresses with her friends while he goes to get drinks for both of them (deeply considering a spiked one for himself), and the very first person he runs into is Blair. It's obviously on purpose because she's directly in his path, an unnerving smile curling her lips. That should've been the first sign.
"I'm shocked you didn't bring Serena as your date." Blair's gaze shifts past him to where Jenny is showing off her handmade beaded purse. "But then I didn't figure you for a cradle robber either."
"Jenny's nice," Nate tries with a shrug. "She's just a friend."
Blair's tongue curls against her teeth. "You have a lot of friends, don't you," she says.
Not really, Nate thinks. He wonders just how risky it would be to try to apologize to her now. At least she's speaking to him.
"Have a nice night, I suppose," Blair says, nose wrinkling slightly. "Send your mother my regards; she always did know how to throw a party."
Nate releases a slow breath once she's moved on, thinking that might truly be it. He might escape the night with some glaring and muttering, nearly unscathed.
Serena keeps Dan busy on the dance floor but as soon as she gives him a breather, Nate carefully disengages from Jenny (who had been breaking down the current season of
America's Next Top Model for him, unasked) to head over. Dan is getting a bottle of water, looking distinctly out of breath, with his collar and tie askew. Nate itches to fix them – or really just wrap his hand in Dan's tie to pull him closer.
He settles for tugging at Dan's jacket to get his attention. Dan turns, an automatic smile on his face when he sees Nate that Nate can't help but return. "You know," Nate says. "I have heard really good things about the coat check at this place."
Dan's smile widens, and his eyebrow arches a little. "Oh, you have, huh?"
They don't actually end up in coat check. They end up in a storage closet, Nate pressed back against the closed door. Tuxedo jackets don't do much for arm mobility, so Nate settles for curling his hand around Dan's tie like he wanted, leaning into Dan's hand where it cups his cheek. It's like the knot of tension in his stomach eases, if only for a moment. Everything might suck and Blair might hate him and Serena might be miserable and it might all be Nate's fault, but for five minutes he gets to kiss someone he likes and feel sort of normal.
Before they go back in, Nate straightens Dan's collar, smoothes his jacket, sets him to rights. The smile Dan gives him in return is one of his softest.
Jenny is waiting at the entrance to the main room, arms crossed and foot tapping. Nate hadn't thought they'd been
that long.
Her tight shoulders drop when she sees them, face taking on a resolved expression. "You probably shouldn't go in there," Jenny says. "Like, really."
Dan and Nate exchange a glance, but Nate has that all too familiar sinking feeling. "Check your phone," he tells Dan, and then tries to be the brave guy he always fails at being by walking past Jenny into the room.
Everyone seems to notice him at once, and then the spotlight even swings brightly in his direction. People are snickering a little but Nate does his best to ignore them, searching out Blair in the crowd. He is not stupid, but he really should have known better.
He doesn't see her, not at first, but what he does see are all those huge screens. And what he hears is Dan behind him breathing a heartfelt, "Oh fuck."
All the screens are showing the same thing – him and Dan after cotillion. Nate sits, Dan kneels in front of him, and they're kissing. Over and over in a loop is their kiss, their very first real kiss, blown up to ridiculous proportions for their classmates to get a good laugh out of. Nate finally locks eyes with Blair, finding hers impassive and cold.
Nate thinks Dan pretty much summed it up.
Fuck.
Part Five